Japanese Earthquake and Tsunami: Did Japan “Deserve” It?

One would hope that in the face of terrible tragedy, people can overcome their racism to, you know, become decent, compassionate human beings.

Instead, people are taking an unimaginable natural disaster and using it as a reason to justify why the Japanese “deserved” such devastation. To document and combat the ignornant Twitter and Facebook updates emerging online, Karma Japan began taking and posting screenshots of many Tweeters saying the disaster was “karma” or “payback” for the 1941 attack on Pearl Harbor, which happened over 70 years– and one World War– ago. There were enough so many tweets along these lines to make “Pearl Harbor” a popular trending topic on Twitter. One notable Tweeter, television writer Alec Sulkin who has over 160,000 followers said, “If you wanna feel better about this earthquake in Japan, google “Pearl Harbor death toll.” It was retweeted by over 100 over his followers within 4 hours. (A day later, Sulkin apologized and deleted his original tweet: “Yesterday death toll = 200. Today = 10 thousand. I am sorry for my insensitive tweet. It’s gone.” Only 75 people retweeted the apology after more than 24 hours.) For the record, the death toll at Pearl Harbor was approximately 2,400. It is likely that that the death toll in Japan will exceed that number by several fold, but regardless of the numbers, is it okay to compare the reasoning behind an act of war to that of an act of nature?

Japan Probe also posted a story about this phenomenon, also citing anti-whaling groups getting in on the anti-Japan action, as well. In a separate, but related story, Captain Paul Watson, the head of Sea Shepherd Conservation Society wrote a poem celebrating the tsunami as the “fearful wrath” of the angry sea god Neptune.

All of this underscores the hatred and ignorance that still exists out there against Japan and the lack of compassion for innocent Japanese victims. Even though the United States and Japan have been allies for decades, people still use Pearl Harbor as a reason to hate Japan.

That is a scary thought– even scarier than the fact that “Godzilla” was also trending during the first 24 hours after the footage of Japanese people fleeing tsunami was being shown around the world. “But not, it turns out, because everyone on Twitter was making tasteless Godzilla jokes in response to scenes of devastation in Japan. It would appear that some Twitterers, inevitably, did, which prompted plenty of outrage. Widespread complaining on Twitter about Godzilla jokes, of course, just helped “Godzilla” surge into the Trending Topics list.”

There are many ways to contribute to the Japanese earthquake relief efforts. Needless to say, no one “deserves” to go through what Japan has gone through.

h/t: K and Chris

Thanks for rating this! Now tell the world how you feel - .
How does this post make you feel?
  • Excited
  • Fascinated
  • Amused
  • Bored
  • Sad
  • Angry

6 Responses to “Japanese Earthquake and Tsunami: Did Japan “Deserve” It?”



  • This makes me sad. Did people forget that we dropped 2 bombs on Japan in WWII? I mean not 1, but 2! How many deaths does it take for a country to stop “deserving” it?

    Seriously people are just ignorant. Wow, that makes me a little sick, and I almost want to denounce my American citizenship. Seriously, people need to grow up.


  • I don’t see a problem with Watson’s poem in itself, it’s quite good. Pretty poor judgement for him to post it when and where he did though given what a controversial figure he is in Japan related circles.

    The whole Rape of Nanking, Pearl Harbour comparison, however, the mind staggers to comprehend their ignorance. So sad.

    Good to see Godwin’s law holding true in the Japan Probe comments.


  • I knew there was a reason I stopped bothering with Twitter.


  • I don’t think anyone deserves a natural disaster, but I always find it interesting when people [mostly Americans] compare the number of casualties at Pearl Harbour to the current tragedy in Japan. It’s not just the Americans who suffered! But of course it’s always about them…do people in the states realize the devastation the Japanese government brought to the rest of Asia? So, it’s not just 2400 deaths in WWII. Americans are both ignorant and arrogant.


  • Do you realize, Japan makes most of our technology?

    OHH KARMA IS A BITCH HUH JAPAN???

    Well no, Good luck getting your shits now, Japan is a large producer of our technology, and if you want to get vengeful, there goes your money too.


  • They do not deserve this. Karma, to me, is not real. It only makes one more aware of a payback (good or bad) so any sign can be it. Mistakes are made and you learn from them, sometimes it takes more than once. To say they deserve is to be ignorant.
    If there is any karma then I am it. To me I am the karma police. Keeping track of what happens to me by others in the past can sometimes change how I behave in the future, to that person or people, or life attitude in general.

Leave a Reply




%d bloggers like this: